What happens when you overprice your home?

May 22, 2025

This is one of the most common seller mistakes, but here’s why it might actually cost you:

It’s peak season and the market is hot… It can be tempting to list your home high to “leave room to negotiate.”

Here’s why that strategy might backfire:

1. FIRST IMPRESSIONS

Right when your home first hits the market is when you’ll get peak interest. Buyers and their agents are watching the market closely — and if the price is too high, they’ll scroll right past.


2. DAYS ON MARKET

The longer your home sits at a higher price, the more people will wonder “Is there is something wrong with the property?”. You’ll also waste your time and delay your own moving timeline.


3. LOW BALL OFFERS

Eventually an overpriced listing might get an offer, but they are almost ALWAYS far below your listing price with terms that may not be beneficial to you. We don’t want you to be offended or desperate, so its better to start off right at the right listing price. 


4. FAILED APPRAISALS

Even if you get an offer with a loan involved, the appraisal might not meet the contract price. That means price cuts or credits to the buyers, delays, or a deal that falls apart.

SO WHAT SHOULD YOU DO INSTEAD? 


Price it right from the start.


A well-priced home gets attention, multiple offers, and better terms.


Here’s how:



Work with a local expert Realtor.


We know the Idaho market and will compare your home to the competition on the market, look at the current market trends and provide you with a CMA (Comparable Market Analysis) suggesting a listing price that will get you attention and top dollar.


Want to SELL your home? Call us today!
Call Us
21 BUYER STEPS

FREE DOWNLOAD

TO PURCHASE A HOME
Get the full PDF download
DOWNLOAD
By Bonners Ferry Herald September 18, 2024
Best Realtor - 1st Place Best Commercial Realtor - 2nd Place Best Real Estate Agency - Century 21 Four Seasons - 2nd Place
September 16, 2024
Step 10 - You've Sold Your Home!
By Darci Price July 7, 2026
PENDING - 2752 sq ft fixer upper home in town on a 0.12 acres!
By Darci Price July 1, 2026
PRICE REDUCED - Private 6 acre hilltop retreat with 2485 sq ft home and mountain views
By Kirsten Madden June 25, 2026
NEW LISTING - 42 acres just outside of Bonners FErry!
By Kirsten Madden June 25, 2026
NEW LISTING - 11.42 acres just outside of Bonners FErry!
By Joanna Rice June 22, 2026
REDUCED - 800 sq ft Manufactured home in Moyie Springs!
By Adriana Rice June 22, 2026
REDUCEd - Private 5.09 acre property on the North Bench with two homes!
By Adriana Rice June 22, 2026
PENDING - 2 bed 1 bath home on 3.16 acres set up for horses and stunning mountain views!
By Kirsten Madden June 19, 2026
REDUCED - 2 story home built in 2024 on 1 acre in Bonners Ferry!
By Darci Price June 15, 2026
FOR SALE - Country Living at this 6.28 acre property!
By Darci Price June 15, 2026
PENDING - 1764 sq ft fixer upper home in town on a 0.25 acre!
Show More

Share This: